The Best Charcoal Grill 2023: Tested and Reviewed

Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill

Features and specifications

Welcome to grilling paradise! When it comes to charcoal grills, we’ve found the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill to be quite the competitor. It sits comfortably at the top of our list of best grills for 2023. This beauty offers great cooking control with its crank handle to raise and lower the charcoal tray – a godsend for those who appreciate precise temperature control.

Crank handle for easy cooking control

Can you imagine having trouble-free temperature adjustments right at your fingertips? Yes, the crank handle on this charcoal grill makes it a piece of cake to raise or lower the charcoal tray. It’s perfect for those seeking juicy, tender results with minimal effort on their part. You’ll be the king or queen of the barbecue before you know it!

Front access door for charcoal management

We’ve all been there: you’re in the middle of a cookout, and you need to add or adjust the coals. With the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill, there’s no need to fuss and fret about how to do it. The front access door makes it a breeze to add or manage the coals while you’re cooking. Absolutely brilliant, wouldn’t you say?

Cleanup with slide-out ash tray and removable cooking grate

Nobody loves the cleanup part of grilling, but the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill makes it bearable. With its slide-out ash tray and removable cooking grates, cleaning up is as simple as 1-2-3. Just when you thought it couldn’t get any better… it does!

Assembly challenges and tips

Now, if there’s one drawback to the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill, it’s the assembly. Fear not, though, because we’re here to help. Some users have reported that the machine holes don’t always match up properly, but a little elbow grease and patience will sort that out in a jiffy. So, grab a buddy, throw on your favorite tunes, and get to assembling. It’ll be worth it in the end – trust us.

Warranty and customer support

As for the warranty, it’s somewhat limited. The grill body has coverage for a modest five years, while other parts are covered for just one year – not the most generous warranty we’ve seen, but not the worst either. That said, Char-Griller has a reputation for providing decent customer support, so you’ll be in good hands should you need assistance.

So, grillmasters and aspiring grill gurus, we present to you the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill as our top pick for 2023. While it may not be perfect, it’s an absolute powerhouse of a grill that truly shines in terms of cooking control, charcoal management, and ease of cleanup. Fire up those coals and let the epic grilling adventures begin!

See this on sale at Amazon!

Testing Charcoal Grills

When it comes to choosing the best charcoal grill for 2023, we’ve gone through all the necessary steps and thorough testing to give you the most accurate and reliable information. We’ve divided our testing process into several categories, which include assembling the grill, testing heat capabilities, cooking various meats, evaluating grill marks and doneness of the cooked meats, and comparing efficiency and ease of use.

Assembling the Grill

Starting right out of the box, we noticed that the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill’s assembly can be somewhat challenging. We found that some machine holes didn’t match up properly, which gave us a bit of a headache. Make sure you have some patience when you tackle this step!

Testing Heat Capabilities

With assembly behind us, we focused on how well the Char-Griller retained and manipulated heat. We found that it excels in this area. Its crank handle, which raises and lowers the charcoal tray, provides exceptional control over the heat output. It’s also got a front access door, making it a breeze to add or manipulate coals while you’re grilling – a feature we wish more grills had.

Cooking Various Meats

Next, we fired up the grill and cooked a wide range of meats. From juicy steaks to tender chicken and delicious sausages, the Char-Griller performed admirably. This grill’s temperature controls allow for a hassle-free cooking experience, enabling us to achieve the perfect sear on our steaks and cook our chicken through to perfection.

Grill Marks and Doneness Evaluation

No barbecue is complete without those enticing grill marks, and we noticed that the Char-Griller delivers on that front. The cooking grates are not only functional but also boast an excellent design that consistently provides mouth-watering grill marks. Doneness was easy to evaluate; with a little know-how, we were able to cook a range of meats just the way we wanted.

Comparing Efficiency and Ease of Use

During our comparison tests, we took a look at the Weber Performer as another option. While it’s mostly an upgraded version of the Original 22″ kettle grill, the upgrades mainly focus on extra features and not performance or cooking surface area. The Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill stood out due to its superior cooking control and quality results, especially when it comes to heat retention and manipulation.

Lastly, we evaluated how easy it is to clean the grill after use. The Char-Griller comes with a slide-out ashtray and removable cooking grate pieces, making the cleanup process manageable. Bear in mind that the Char-Griller warranty is limited, with grill body coverage for five years and other parts for just one year. However, we are confident that this grill is a solid value considering its advantageous features and performance.

You may encounter a few bumps in the road when first assembling the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill, but once you get it up and running, you’ll be delighted with its excellent cooking capabilities, heat control, and ease of use. We think it’s a top contender for 2023!

Factors to Consider in a Charcoal Grill

When you’re on the hunt for the best charcoal grill to make your cookouts an unforgettable experience, there are several key factors to consider. In this post, we’ll dive deep into each of them to help you make the most informed decision possible. So, grab a cold one and let’s get grilling!

Materials and stability

First and foremost, you’ll want to look for a grill made from high-quality materials that can withstand high heat and weather exposure. This will not only impact the grill’s performance but also its durability and longevity. Look for grills made from heavy-duty steel with porcelain or stainless steel grates for optimal heat retention and rust resistance.

Additionally, a stable grill is a safe grill. Ensure that the legs are sturdy, and the wheels (if it has any) are securely attached. A wobbly grill can lead to accidents and spilt food, neither of which we want at our backyard BBQs!

Heat retention and manipulation

A great charcoal grill should be able to retain heat effectively, and allow you to easily control the temperature for different types of cooking, be it low-and-slow or searing hot. Look for grills with thick, well-insulated walls and lids that create an oven-like environment for even heat distribution.

Additionally, adjustable vents are a must for controlling air-flow and manipulating the temperature inside the cooking chamber. Keep an eye out for grills with multiple vents that can be opened or closed as needed to fine-tune the cooking temperature.

Grate functionality

The grate is where the magic happens. Grates should be made from rust-resistant materials like stainless steel or porcelain-coated cast iron and designed for even cooking results.

Consider grates with a hinged or removable section, which can make adding and manipulating charcoal a breeze, without having to remove the grate entirely.

Finally, ask yourself how important grill marks are to you. Grates with thicker bars will create more pronounced sear marks, while thinner bars provide a more even heat transfer across the entire surface of the meat.

Advanced grill features

While the classic kettle-style charcoal grill can deliver outstanding results, many modern grills come with bells and whistles that level up the grilling game. Features like built-in thermometers, adjustable charcoal trays, crank handles, and side tables can make your grilling experience more convenient and enjoyable.

Keep in mind, however, that some features may not significantly improve your grilling results and might just jack up the price. Focus on the features that truly matter to you and your grilling style.

Ease of cleanup and maintenance

Nobody likes spending hours cleaning up after a cookout, so look for grills with features that make cleanup a breeze, such as slide-out ash trays, removable cooking grate pieces, and easy-to-empty grease management systems.

Pay attention to the warranty, too. Extended warranty coverage can give you peace of mind knowing that, should any issues arise, you won’t be left holding the bag (or rather, the grill).

By considering these factors, you’ll be well-equipped to pick out a charcoal grill that not only meets your needs, but also elevates your outdoor cooking game. Happy grilling!

Weber Performer Charcoal Grill

Overview of features

When it comes to the Weber Performer, we’re talking about a charcoal grill that delivers a great cooking experience with some extra bells and whistles. It’s essentially an upgraded version of the well-loved Weber Original 22″ Kettle Grill but boasts a few improvements.

Comparing with Char-Griller Classic

While the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill offers great control over the cooking process with its crank handle that raises and lowers the charcoal tray, the Weber Performer provides a similar level of control with its One-Touch Cleaning System. We found that both grills have their unique advantages; however, the most significant difference is in the added features that the Weber Performer offers.

Upgrade focus: extra features vs performance

When it comes to features, the Weber Performer shines. This charcoal grill comes with a built-in, easy-to-read lid thermometer, tool hooks, a removable aluminum ash catcher, and even a stainless steel side table. These additional features not only make grilling a breeze but also provide a more convenient and comfortable experience as you whip up tasty BBQ treats.

However, it’s essential to note that these upgrades aren’t necessarily focused on improved performance or a larger cooking surface area. Essentially, the cooking performance you’ll get from the Weber Performer and the Original 22″ Kettle Grill is pretty much the same.

Cooking surface area comparison

One thing that may catch your attention is the cooking surface area. While the Char-Griller Classic offers a considerable cooking surface, the Weber Performer isn’t far behind. Both charcoal grills provide ample space for cooking your favorite grilled meats and veggies, so you won’t feel strapped for space, no matter which grill you choose.

Price and value for money

In terms of price, the Weber Performer Charcoal Grill does come with a heftier price tag than the Char-Griller Classic. However, the value for money is there, especially when you consider the additional features that come with the Performer. If you’re willing to splurge a bit and invest in a charcoal grill with all the bells and whistles, the Weber Performer is the way to go.

Both grills have their advantages, and ultimately, the best charcoal grill for you will depend on your personal preferences and priorities. Whether you’re looking for the perfect BBQ experience or just want a grill that’s easy to use and maintain, the Weber Performer and Char-Griller Classic are both solid contenders for the title of “Best Charcoal Grill 2023.” So, gear up, light those charcoals, and get ready to grill like a pro this summer!

See the Amazon pricing<<<<

Other Charcoal Grill Options

While the Char-Griller Classic Charcoal Grill takes the cake as our top choice for the best charcoal grill of 2023, we understand that there are other options available to cater to individual needs and preferences. Therefore, we’ve explored additional categories of charcoal grills, and we’re delighted to share our findings with you.

Portable Charcoal Grills

For those who love to pack a punch when they’re on the go, portable charcoal grills are the way to go. These compact grills provide the same authentic charcoal grilling experience, but in a more travel-friendly package. Check out options like the Weber Go-Anywhere Charcoal Grill or the Char-Broil Portable Charcoal Grill. These little dynamos have foldable legs or carrying handles, making them ideal for your next tailgate party or camping trip.

Charcoal Grills for Small Spaces

If you don’t have a sprawling backyard but still crave the unbeatable taste of charcoal-grilled food, fear not! We’ve got you covered with some terrific charcoal grills for small spaces like patios, terraces, or balconies. Consider picking up the Weber Original 18″ Kettle Grill or the Cuisinart CCG-190RB Portable Charcoal Grill. These compact grills offer a great balance between cooking power and space-saving design.

High-End Charcoal Grills

For all the grill masters out there seeking to elevate their grilling game with a luxury touch, high-end charcoal grills offer you all the bells and whistles combined with quality materials and excellent cooking performance. Grills like the Kamado Joe Classic II and the Weber Summit Charcoal Grill fall in this category, boasting premium features such as precise temperature control, insulated walls for better heat retention, and even integrated lighting for those night-time grilling sessions.

Novelty and Specialty Charcoal Grills

If you’re looking for something truly unique to grill on or have a special type of food that you want to achieve perfection on, novelty and specialty charcoal grills are your destination. Choices like the Lodge Cast Iron Sportsman’s Grill or the unusual Fuego Element Carbon Steel Grill cater to specific grilling styles and add a conversation-starting element to your outdoor cooking adventures.

Remember, ultimately, the best charcoal grill for you is the one that fits your specific needs and preferences. We encourage you to explore these categories to find the grill of your dreams and enjoy countless delicious meals grilled to perfection. Happy grilling!

Accessories for Charcoal Grilling

Alright, folks! So you’ve chosen your ideal charcoal grill for 2023. But we know that it takes more than just the perfect grill to have a killer barbeque. So let’s dive into some game-changing accessories, shall we?

Charcoal chimney starters

Fire up that grill with ease by using a charcoal chimney starter. These nifty gadgets ensure a consistent, even heat distribution by allowing you to light your charcoal fast and without any hassle. Just fill the chimney with charcoal, light it up, and let it do its thing. Once the coals are glowing hot, simply dump them into your grill’s charcoal tray. Et voilà! You’re ready to get your cook on.

Grilling tools and utensils

Ah, the mighty grilling tools – the unsung heroes of any successful BBQ. Invest in a quality set of stainless steel utensils, including a spatula, tongs, and grill fork. Trust us, these babies will be your trusty sidekicks as you flip, turn, and poke your way to culinary perfection.

Grill covers and cleaning supplies

Let’s be real, nobody likes a rusty and dirty grill. Keep your beloved charcoal grill in tip-top shape by using a weather-resistant grill cover and a grill brush with a good scraper. The cover will shield your grill from the elements, while the grill brush will make sure food debris and ash don’t stand a chance. Plus, a clean grill results in tastier food, so win-win!

Temperature control and monitoring

Eye-balling the doneness of your meat can be a risky business. That’s why we recommend investing in a quality instant-read thermometer. Whatever you’re grilling – whether it’s a juicy steak or tender chicken – a reliable thermometer will help you get that perfect level of succulency every. single. time.

And let’s not forget about heat control. Remember, the key to exceptional grilling is mastering temperature manipulation. Consider buying a quality grill with adjustable vents or even a model that comes with a built-in thermometer. It’ll take your grilling game to a whole new level.

Lighting solutions for nighttime grilling

Sunset? Who cares! You can keep the good times rolling and the BBQ sizzlin’ with some outdoor, waterproof lighting. From magnetic LED lights that attach to your grill to weather-resistant patio string lights that create a cozy atmosphere, the options are endless. Just make sure you have sufficient lighting to keep a keen eye on your delicious, flame-kissed creations.

There you have it, guys! With these essential grilling accessories, you’ll be a true master of the charcoal grill in no time. So grab your shades, slap on some sunscreen, and prepare to amaze your friends and family with your newfound BBQ prowess in 2023. Happy grilling!

Safety Tips for Charcoal Grilling

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty of our top charcoal grill picks for 2023, it’s important to discuss a few safety tips. After all, a great grilling experience isn’t complete without ensuring the wellbeing of everyone around the grill. So, without further ado, let’s get into it.

Proper Ventilation

First things first, folks: proper ventilation is crucial when dealing with charcoal grills. After all, the last thing we want is a build-up of nasty carbon monoxide, right? This sneaky, odorless gas is produced during combustion, so to avoid asphyxiation or worse, always position your grill in an open, outdoor area, well away from enclosed spaces and flammable materials. Trust us: better safe than sorry!

Fire Safety

Speaking of safety, let’s talk about fires, shall we? It’s no secret that grilling can be a fire hazard, but with a little know-how and preparation, we can keep things under control. First, make sure you have a fire extinguisher handy, as well as a bucket of sand or a reliable water source nearby. Avoid using lighter fluid to kick-start your charcoal grill, as it’s a prime cause of flare-ups. Instead, opt for a chimney starter or fire starters to get the party going.

Handling Hot Surfaces

Alright, folks, now that we’ve got ventilation and fire safety covered, let’s turn our attention to the unavoidable: hot surfaces. As sturdy and resilient as our grills might be, they’re not immune to the heat, and neither are we. To avoid burns or grill mishaps, always use protective gloves and long-handled tools specifically designed for grilling. Remember, better safe than tender!

Food Safety and Handling

The last thing we want is our mouth-watering grilled feast turning sour due to improper food handling. Take a few precautions to avoid any culinary faux pas. Keep raw and cooked foods on separate platters and utensils, and always use a food thermometer to ensure your meats are cooked to a safe temperature. After all, nobody wants an uninvited guest like food poisoning crashing the party.

Child and Pet Awareness Around Grills

Let’s face it, folks: our grilling get-togethers usually involve the whole family, and that includes the little ones and our four-legged friends. But with fun comes responsibility, so make sure you keep an eye out for curious kiddos and pets wandering too close to the grill. Set a safety perimeter or use barriers if needed to keep them at a safe distance. After all, good times and safety go hand in hand, right?

In conclusion, while we’re all here for a good time, it’s essential to keep these safety tips in mind and practice them every time we fire up our charcoal grills. Happy grilling, everyone!

Frequently Asked Questions

We know that choosing the right charcoal grill can be a bit overwhelming, with all the options and features available. To make your decision a little easier, we’ve answered some of the most common questions people have when shopping for a charcoal grill.

What is the ideal cooking temperature for a charcoal grill?

The ideal cooking temperature for a charcoal grill depends on what you’re grilling. For most foods, a cooking temperature between 350°F and 450°F is perfect. However, certain items like steak may require higher temperatures, around 500°F to sear and cook properly. In any case, it’s always a good idea to have a reliable thermometer handy to help you monitor the temperature inside your grill.

How do I maximize the life of my charcoal grill?

To maximize the life of your charcoal grill, perform regular maintenance and cleaning. This includes brushing off ash and debris from the cooking grates after each use, emptying the ash tray, and wiping down the grill body. Also, be sure to store your grill in a dry, covered area to protect it from the elements. Regularly inspect your grill for any issues, such as rust or loose screws/bolts, and address these issues as needed.

Are briquettes or lump charcoal better for grilling?

Both briquettes and lump charcoal have their pros and cons. Briquettes tend to provide longer, more consistent heat and are often less expensive than lump charcoal. However, they can contain additives or binders that may affect the flavor of your food. Lump charcoal, on the other hand, is made from pure wood and provides a more natural, smoky flavor. It also lights faster and can burn hotter than briquettes. Ultimately, the choice between briquettes and lump charcoal comes down to personal preference and what you prioritize during grilling.

How can I minimize flare-ups while grilling?

To minimize flare-ups on your charcoal grill, maintain a clean cooking surface by brushing off excess residue after each use. You can also avoid using fatty meats or trim excess fat before grilling. If flare-ups do occur, try moving your food to a different area of the grill or placing a drip pan underneath to catch any excess grease. Also, avoid opening the grill lid too often, as this can cause flare-ups by allowing oxygen to fuel the fire.

What should I look for in a good grill cover?

A good grill cover should be made from a durable, weather-resistant material like vinyl, polyester, or heavy-duty fabric. Look for features like elastic cords or drawstrings to help secure the cover tightly around your grill, as well as vents to prevent condensation and promote airflow. It’s also a good idea to find a cover that’s specifically designed to fit your grill model, as this ensures the best possible protection.

Can I use a charcoal grill indoors or on a balcony?

As tempting as it may be to fire up your charcoal grill indoors on a rainy day or on your apartment balcony, it’s not recommended. Charcoal grills produce large amounts of carbon monoxide and other chemicals, which can be dangerous when used in enclosed spaces. Always use your charcoal grill outdoors and in a well-ventilated area, away from any flammable materials. Additionally, check your building or local regulations regarding the use of charcoal grills, as some areas may have restrictions in place.